A friend invited me to an advanced screening of a new horror film, “Saw.” From what I understand this movie is debuting at Sundance tonight (I might be wrong about the day) at a midnight showing, so I actually got a chance to see this film before all those industry wanks. I’m going to share my thoughts on this film without any spoilers, which is a little tough due to the nature of the story, but considering this movie isn’t going to hit theater’s until who knows when, it’s best I don’t give too much away.
“Saw” is a horror flick that’s heavy on the psychological horror. This movie contains no zombies, werewolves or any of that stuff, so those of you who shy away from horror films with those elements (shame on you), this just might be your bag. The advance hype on this film compares “Saw” to David Fincher’s “Seven” or a Nine Inch Nails video. That’s really going to be unfair. When you see it you’ll say, sure, that’s about right, but let’s talk about the movie by itself without comparing it to everything else.
How to describe the film without giving away the plot. Well, there’s a serial killer on the loose who’s got a real twisted sense of the good times. The killer places its victims into horrible situations and forces them to try to find a way out. If you don’t try, you’ll die. If you do try, well, you’ll most likely die a horrible death, but at least you tried (That cliché about close only counts in horse shoes, well, yeah, it’s fucking true). Saying much more than that about the movie I hurt the chances of the film having an affect on you. So that’s all you get. Do some research on your own if you want to know more.
As a whole the movie works nicely and does a good job of making you want to crap the dook. There are a couple of very good “shock” moments you’ll react physically to and some of the imagery is very nicely designed. There’s one particular device a victim wears that fucked with my cranium for a while.
The film is directed by first time director James Wan. He’s all of 24 or 25 years old. If you took a look at him he’d strike you as unremarkable in every way. Just another mid-twenties skater like looking dude. He does an able job with the cast, which includes Cary Elwes, Danny Glover and first time actor Leigh Whannell, who also wrote the film. Wan sets a great sense of dread throughout the film with creepy settings and interesting camera tricks. This is a movie best enjoyed in a dark movie theater. Some of the action sequences are quite excellent and really help get the heart pounding.
Letting out the nit-picker in me, the biggest problems with the movie are also with the directing and some of the acting. The movie, as a whole, works, but at moments there are scenes where you can tell it’s a first time director and not a seasoned veteran who would know to avoid such mistakes. Wan uses a number of film tricks we’ve seen numerous times in recent years that aren’t at all necessary. They tend to distract more than they add to the horror. At other times Wan redeems himself nicely, especially in a scene in Whannell’s apartment using the only light he has available to him. Nicely done.
“Saw,” as I saw it, could also stand some quick re-editing. No need to take out any scenes, but reworking some scenes better would hide some of the problems with actor Leigh Whannell. Leigh does a mostly good job throughout the film, but there are some jarring moments with his delivery. At other times, especially those filled with great moments of fear, Leigh does more than an able job.
Where Whannell falls short in the acting category, he comes through with the story which is really a good one with just a couple of flaws. The reveal of the “villain” is a bit obvious at one point, but they make up for it towards the end (note I’m doing my best not to give away anything here). But, it’s the ending that while decent, falls short of being really strong. From what I understand, Wan and Whannell are Australian’s, which is actually a help when making a proper horror film. So often in American cinema horror films fall flat due to their need for a “Hollywood ending.” It’s rare you leave the theater after an American horror film with a real feeling of dread or misery. With “Saw” you don’t get that happy ending, but what they give you requires the audience to just accept certain things and say, “Okay, I guess that could be.” I left the theater having that sense of dread about five minutes before the end, but then it goes away once the credits roll.
“Saw” is a horror film with a mystery to be solved, so the over-active mind I have was constantly trying to figure out where things were going. If you pay close attention to the events that transpire you should without much difficulty figure out where the film makers will take you next. With “Saw” that’s not a horrible thing. It kind of prepares you for the horror that comes next, which you’ll be thankful for.
Cary Elwes gives the strongest performance in the movie. It’s a very different part for him to play and his all-but unrecognizable at first. He looks older in this movie and heavier than I’ve ever seen him before. Danny Glover plays a role similar to ones he’s played in the past (he’s a cop, again) and does an able job. I enjoyed Monica Potter as Elwes’ wife in the movie. She had some excellent moments towards the end.
All in all I’m really quite pleased with “Saw.” Entertaining and scary, it’s not perfect, nor does it fail. If I had to quantify it I guess I’d give it a seven or eight on a one to ten scale. I really do feel that with a just a jiggers worth of editing (oh and some looping, geeze, some of the dialogue had serious problems both with words and sound) the film could be even more successful.
One odd thing was seeing a horror film in the middle of the day. The screening happened at Noon. I’ve never come out of a horror film into broad daylight. That was possibly the oddest part of the whole experience.